Aaron Rodgers' list of controversies: Has the superstar QB tarnished his legacy for good?

A once bright star
Slowly going dark
A tarnished legacy?
COVID-19 lie
Sick of woke mobs
Bad vibes in Green Bay
All started with Jordan Love
Was never the same there again
Family drama
Out of favour with family
Family matters should be private
Politcal rants
An all round skeptic
Unlucky in love?
At odds with his former fiancé
Political differences
What will his legacy be?
A once bright star
For much of his career, Aaron Rodgers was known for his incredible talent on the football field. The Green Bay Packers legend, now leading the New York Jets, became one of the NFL’s most decorated quarterbacks, with a Super Bowl title and multiple MVP awards.
Slowly going dark

In recent years, his off-field controversies have started to overshadow his on-field accomplishments. Once seen as a squeaky-clean superstar, Rodgers has found himself embroiled in a series of incidents that have raised eyebrows and soured his reputation.

A tarnished legacy?

Here’s a look at some of the key controversies that have followed Rodgers, causing many to question the legacy of the NFL icon.

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

COVID-19 lie

One of the most prominent controversies surrounding Rodgers erupted during the 2021 NFL season. When asked if he was vaccinated against COVID-19, Rodgers responded that he was "immunized." This led many to believe he had received the vaccine, only for it to be revealed later that he had not been vaccinated according to league protocols.

Sick of woke mobs

Rodgers then defended his stance, claiming he was allergic to an ingredient in the mRNA vaccines and that he sought alternative treatments. His comments about "woke mobs" and "cancel culture" in interviews with the media, particularly on The Pat McAfee Show, sparked a firestorm of criticism. Many viewed his actions as misleading and felt betrayed by his lack of transparency. Rodgers’ attempt to cast himself as a victim in the situation only intensified the backlash.

Bad vibes in Green Bay

Rodgers' rocky relationship with the Green Bay Packers’ front office had been simmering for years before it finally boiled over in 2021. Reports surfaced that Rodgers was unhappy with the team’s management, specifically over personnel decisions and the lack of communication.

All started with Jordan Love

The tipping point appeared to be the Packers' selection of quarterback Jordan Love in the first round of the 2020 NFL Draft without consulting Rodgers, as Green Bay fan site Packers Wire reports.

Was never the same there again

Rodgers hinted at retirement, skipped voluntary team workouts, and even demanded a trade, effectively holding the team’s future hostage for months, as The Washington Post put it. While he ultimately returned to the Packers for one more season, his public criticism of the organization strained his relationship with fans and left many questioning his loyalty to the franchise that had made him a star.

Family drama

Rodgers’ strained relationship with his family has long been a subject of media speculation. The quarterback has been notably distant from his parents and siblings, and in a rare public comment, his brother, Jordan Rodgers, once mentioned on The Bachelorette while he was a contestant in 2016, that Aaron had no contact with the family.

Out of favour with family

Reports, from the likes of ESPN among others, suggested that tensions escalated after Rodgers' rise to fame, with disagreements over his lifestyle choices and romantic relationships cited as potential reasons for the rift.

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

Family matters should be private

Rodgers has mostly kept quiet about the situation, saying in a 2017 New York Times interview that family matters should remain private. However, the public nature of the family feud has tarnished his image, with some fans speculating that his off-field relationships reflect poorly on his character.

Politcal rants

Rodgers has never shied away from sharing his opinions on social issues, and while some appreciate his candidness, others find his comments divisive. His 2021 remarks on the COVID-19 vaccine were not the first or last time he courted controversy with his views.

An all round skeptic

In particular, his criticism of government policies and skepticism of the pandemic response earned him criticism from both fans and commentators. While many athletes use their platforms to speak out on issues, Rodgers tends to go for more conspiratorial topics.

"I don’t know who’s actually running the country"

As he told Look Into It With Eddie Bravo in 2024. "It seemed like there are certain members of the establishment who stayed in power or got to power. Biden. I mean, he’s a puppet. I don’t know who’s actually running the country, whether it’s somebody else, but he can barely put his sentences together."

Unlucky in love?

Rodgers’ high-profile relationships have also kept him in the tabloids. From his long-term relationship with actress Olivia Munn to his brief engagement to actress Shailene Woodley, Rodgers' love life has frequently made headlines.

At odds with his former fiancé

His engagement to Woodley, in particular, became a focal point after the couple’s differing political views came to light. Woodley, known for her progressive activism, was reportedly at odds with some of Rodgers’ more libertarian-leaning opinions, according to Elle.

 

Political differences

The relationship ended in 2022, with speculation from the aforementioned gossip mag that their political differences played a role. Although personal relationships are often outside the realm of public scrutiny, Rodgers’ romantic entanglements have fed into the broader narrative of a player whose off-field persona is increasingly at odds with his once-sterling reputation.

What will his legacy be?

Aaron Rodgers remains one of the most talented quarterbacks to ever play in the NFL, but his off-field controversies have undeniably chipped away at the once-pristine image he cultivated early in his career. For some, these incidents are seen as signs of a complex and outspoken individual. For others, they have cast a shadow over his accomplishments, leaving many to wonder what his lasting legacy in the game will truly be.

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

More for you