Who are the most overrated players in the Premier League? – with shock additions!

Most watched league
The players
10 - Virgil Van Dijk (Liverpool)
9 - David Raya (Arsenal)
Defence deserves credit
8 - Bruno Guimaraes (Newcastle United)
Losing his head
7 - Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United)
Can go missing
6 - Heung Min Son (Tottenham Hotspur)
No major trophies
5 - Mason Mount (Manchester United)
Proof in the pudding
4 - Marcus Rashford (Manchester United)
Turbulent season
3 - Enzo Fernandez (Chelsea)
Not a difference maker
2 - Nicolas Jackson (Chelsea)
Breaking down his goals
1 - Antony (Manchester United)
Poor return
Most watched league

The Premier League is the most watched and scrutinized football league in the world, with every player watched under a microscope on a matchday. 

The players

Despite the players in the Premier League being heavily scrutinized, some players are viewed in a nicer light when it comes to their performances every week. Here are the most overrated players in the Premier League. 

10 - Virgil Van Dijk (Liverpool)

Yes, this may come as a surprise because of how good Virgil Van Dijk has been for Liverpool in the Premier League, but his performances in recent weeks are why Liverpool has fallen out of Europe and the title race in the Premier League. 

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

"I think he is overrated"

According to Talksport, former Chelsea player Jason Cundy said: "Not only does he head the ball in a direction that you don't want him to. Personally, I think he is overrated." Liverpool has the sixth-best clean sheet rating in the league.

9 - David Raya (Arsenal)

Yes, David Raya has just won the Golden Glove with Arsenal. Still, a lot more of the credit has got to go to William Saliba and Gabriel for that award, with Raya having shaky moments throughout the season, including Tottenham's first goal against Arsenal in April. 

Defence deserves credit

The Golden Glove award effectively gives Raya the title of 'best goalkeeper in the Premier League' this season, but Arsenal's whole defense is why he won the award, not just him. The Premier League website reports the 'Gunners' have kept 17 clean sheets this season.

8 - Bruno Guimaraes (Newcastle United)

Newcastle's Bruno Guimaraes has been one of the main players that has helped Newcastle challenge towards the top end of the Premier League, but unfortunately for Newcastle fans, he isn't one of the best midfielders in the league yet.

Losing his head

With nine yellow cards this season, the Brazilian has been known to let his anger and passion affect some of his performances this year as Newcastle has struggled to reach the top four in the league. To be world-class, Guimaraes will need to improve on six goals and assists. 

7 - Bruno Fernandes (Manchester United)

Let's be clear, Bruno Fernandes is a phenomenal football player, his passing and scoring ability are second to none, but his statistics always outshine how he performs on the pitch, leading to more praise than he probably deserves.

Can go missing

In 33 matches this season, Fernandes has scored ten goals and got seven assists in the Premier League. However, as their talisman, Fernandes has been known to let his anger take over his performances, and he has been known to go missing in big games, scoring one goal against teams in the top six this season.

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

6 - Heung Min Son (Tottenham Hotspur)

Tottenham captain Heung Min Son is a legend of the club and has been there since 2015, winning one Premier League Golden Boot in 2022. The South Korean has scored 17 goals and provided nine assists this season, but it's been the same old story for Spurs.

No major trophies

The South Korean is widely regarded as one of the best forwards in Premier League history, scoring 120 goals in 300 games, but he still hasn't been good enough to take Spurs over the line in a major final or the league. Despite his excellence, Son can't get it done on the biggest stage.

5 - Mason Mount (Manchester United)

Mason Mount has been highly praised by England manager Gareth Southgate and by footballing legend Frank Lampard, but after his big move to Manchester United, Mount has continued to struggle to set the Premier League alight. 

Proof in the pudding

So far this season, Mount has played 14 games and scored one goal due to injuries, but at Chelsea, he has only registered more than ten goals once in the Premier League. Mount isn't a difference-maker and struggles to take teams to the next level.

4 - Marcus Rashford (Manchester United)

Despite scoring 30 goals last season, Marcus Rashford is a player who has very much lived in moments during his footballing career and has not been a consistent performer for United over the years. 

Turbulent season

This season, Rashford has struggled for Manchester United in another turbulent season for the club, hitting the back of the net only seven times in his advanced position. Rashford indeed has talent, but he isn't one of the best attackers in the world.

3 - Enzo Fernandez (Chelsea)

Another Chelsea player who hasn't lived up to the tag some fans have given him is World Cup winner Enzo Fernandez, who's struggled to impact games and remain consistent during Chelsea's tough year.

Not a difference maker

For possessing a midfielder worth around £100 million, Fernandez has struggled to be a difference-maker for Chelsea, scoring only three goals and providing two assists this season. The 'Blues' have averaged 59% possession this season, but their dominance hasn't shown in the results.

2 - Nicolas Jackson (Chelsea)

Labeled as the 'new Drogba' by some Chelsea fans, according to ESPN, Nicolas Jackson's goal return in the Premier League doesn't signal how wasteful he has been for Chelsea this season as they struggle to challenge for European places again.

Breaking down his goals

Jackson has scored 13 goals in the league this season, with three coming against the nine men of Tottenham earlier in the season and five coming against five of the bottom six in the league. The truth is, Jackson hasn't turned up in big games and struggled against better defenders.

1 - Antony (Manchester United)

After joining Manchester United for £85 million, Antony was expected to be the next big thing for United, and some fans believe he will be, but his stats and performances are proof that the Brazilian winger is extremely overrated. 

Poor return

According to the Premier League website, the Brazilian winger has scored one goal and provided one assist in the league this season, following on from four goals and two assists last season. For £85 million, the United fans would hope for much better. 

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

More for you